The Court of Appeal held that findings by the Workers' Compensation Commission can create issue estoppel in subsequent common law proceedings between the same parties, even where the estoppel does not defeat the entire cause of action but only limits certain aspects of damages. The Court established that such estoppel should ordinarily be dealt with during trial as an evidentiary matter, and that s 64a of the Workers' Compensation Act does not prevent defendants from proving the estoppel in evidence. However, the Court held that issue estoppel from workers' compensation proceedings cannot apply to all facets of common law damages, particularly where different types of injury or recurrence of aggravation may have occurred after the Commission's cut-off date.
The full text is available to signed-in members.