This case is a brief appellate order on the sufficiency of evidence to go to a jury, with minimal precedential value given the absence of recorded reasoning.
Craine Plaintiff , Appellant ; and Soden Defendant , Respondent .
H C of A
Griffith C.J., Barton, Isaacs and Rich JJ.
14 March 1916
Griffith C.J., , Barton, Isaacs and Rich JJ.The Court allowed the appeal, holding that there was evidence to go to a jury.
Appeal allowed with costs. Order appealed from discharged. Appeal to the Supreme Court allowed, with costs. Case to be reheard before a Judge of the Supreme Court. Costs in the County Court to abide the event of the rehearing.
Schutt (with him Dixon ), for the appellant.
Starke (with him Lowe ), for the respondent.
Solicitor for the appellant, W. S. Doria .
Solicitors for the respondent, Cleverdon & Fay .