Later decisions that cite Ltd v Valuer-General
The judgment of their Lordships was delivered by
Lorp Dunepin. Their Lordships are of opinion that the
valuation in this case made by the valuer-general and con-
firmed by the judge of the Land and Valuation Court and
the Supreme Court of New South Wales cannot stand. They
consider that the valuation as made proceeds on a principle
which is fallacious, but really stands condemned not so much
on this fallacy as upon the fact that it is made not according
to the method prescribed by the Act of Parliament.
The question is as to the unimproved value of a piece of
ground on which stand buildings occupied as licensed premises.
The method of valuation adopted was as follows: First, an
agreed figure of 24,100/. was taken as the figure that would
be realized if the whole subject was sold as licensed premises.
Secondly, an agreed figure of 10,840/. was put as the value
(1) (1918) 16 C. L. R. 654. (4) (1921) 5 Local Govt. Rep.
(2) (1919) 26 C. L. R. 159. (N.S. W.) 129.
(3) (1905) 25 N. Z. L. R. 225. (5) [1914] A. C. 753.
A. C. AND PRIVY COUNCIL.
of the buildings on the subject, the buildings being appro-
priate to and suitable for the purposes of licensed premises.
443
J.C,
1924
The valuation put on the subject as unimproved value TooHRy's,
was then reached by deducting 10,840]. from 24,100/.—i.e.,
13,2601.
Lp.
Vv
THE
. ° . . VALUER-
Now, the sections of the Act of Parliament dealing with the Genzrat.
matter are as follows :—
Sect. 5: " The improved value of land is the capital sum
which the fee simple of the land might be expected to realise
if offered for sale on such reasonable terms and conditions
as a bona fide seller would require."'
Sect. 6: "The unimproved value of land is the capital
sum which the fee simple of the land might be expected to
realise if offered for sale on such reasonable terms and condi-
tions as a bona fide seller would require, assuming that the
improvements, if any, thereon or appertaining thereto, and
made or acquired by the owner or his predecessor in title,
had not been made."
It is with the latter of the two sections that the valuer has
to do. Now, what he has to consider is what the land would
fetch as at the date of the valuation if the improvements
made had not been made. Words could scarcely be clearer
to show that the improvements were to be left entirely out of
view. They are to be taken, not only as non-existent, but as
if they never had existed. It is, therefore, to approach the
question from a completely wrong point of view to begin with
a valuation which takes in the improvements and then proceed
by means of subtraction of a sum arrived at by an independent
valuation in order to find the required figure. What the
Act requires is really quite simple. Here is a plot of land;
assume that there is nothing on it in the way of improvement ;
what would it fetch in the market ? It will be observed that
the value is not what has been sometimes designated by the
expression 'prairie value." The land must be taken as it
exists at the date of the valuation.
It has again and again been pointed out what the value of
land on compulsory acquisition is, and the principle here is
exactly the same. The value has been formulated by this
HOUSE OF LORDS {1925}
Board in the cases of Cedars Rapids Co. v. Lacoste (1) and
Fraser v. Fraserville City. (2) Citing the former case the value
to the owner consists of all advantages which the land possesses,
present or prospective. In the stated case there is a finding
of a negative character: (/) That the subject land possesses
no special advantages or adaptabilities as a site for licensed
premises by reason of its position or otherwise which render
it more valuable than any similarly situated land in the
immediate neighbourhood. But that negative finding, which
declares that the land is not better as a site for licensed
premises than any other land similarly situated, does not
exclude a value which may adhere to the land in respect
of its suitability.
Their Lordships do not attempt themselves to make a
valuation to be deduced from the figures given, for the simple
reason that the valuer has not applied himself to the only
questions presented to him by the Act, and it is his business
to do so. But, as already said, the result obtained is not
only contrary to the method permitted by the Act, but is
demonstrably fallacious. Proceedings are begun by the
taking of a figure for the subject as it stands as licensed pre-
mises. It is obvious that this figure is composed of three
ingredients ; first, the bare land itself; second, the buildings
themselves constructed for and appropriate for licensed
premises; third, the enhanced value due to the fact that the
land and buildings in question are not only suitable for licensed
premises, but are in fact licensed premises.
When, however, the subtraction sum is entered upon it
is only item 2 that is subtracted from the total figure; the
result being that item 3 is all included in the unimproved
value. From this follows the extraordinary result that the
land is enhanced by the value of a licence which could only
be granted in connection with buildings—for a licence such as
this cannot be granted to sell liquor without premises—in a
calculation in which you are told to assume that no building
is there.
Their Lordships will, therefore, humbly advise His Majesty
(1) [1914] A. C. 569. (2) [1917] A. C. 187.
A. C. AND PRIVY COUNCIL. 445
that the appeal should be allowed and the case remitted to J. C.
the Supreme Court to direct the valuer to make a valuation 1924
of the land itself as it at present stands with such advantages Toouny's,
as it at present possesses, and viewed as bare land without es
any buildings upon it, and without any consideration of the Wie
value of the subject as including de facto licensed premises, Generat.
The respondent will pay the costs before this Board and in
the Courts below.