Challenges to the correctness of electoral rolls, including allegations of wrongful removal of names, cannot be brought before the Court of Disputed Returns and must instead be pursued through the alternative statutory remedies provided by the Act.
Later decisions that cite Re Berrill's Petition
Decisions cited by Re Berrill's Petition
In re BERRILL'S PETITION [1976] HCA 50; (1976) 134 CLR 470
Parliamentary Elections (Cth)
High Court of Australia
Gibbs(1), Stephen(2) and Mason(3) JJ.
CATCHWORDS
Parliamentary Elections (Cth) - Election for Senate - Electoral roll - Names of electors alleged to have been wrongly removed - Petition for declaration that election void - Court of Disputed Returns required not to inquire into correctness of any roll - Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth), s. 190.
HEARING
Adelaide, 1976, September 9.DECISION
October 1.
2. The petition must be dismissed. (at p471)
STEPHEN J. The petitioner, Helen Therese Berrill, by her petition dated
25th February 1976 seeks declarations that no candidate
returned or elected to
the Senate in the State of South Australia in the election held on 13th
December 1975 was duly elected, alternatively
that that election was void.
Certain interlocutory relief is also sought. (at p471)
2. By her petition she alleges that in breach of provisions of the
Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918, as amended, electoral registrars
in the State
of South Australia have, in specified circumstances, removed the names of
electors
from sub-divisional rolls; in consequence
the names of very large
numbers of electors are said to have been wrongly removed from
the rolls. The
petition goes on to assert
the absence of any evidence that such electors
became disqualified from being on an electoral
roll, that they were ever
re-enrolled
or that they voted at the 13th December 1975 election; these
assertions appear to be intended
as allegations that the electors in
question
were not disqualified, have not re-enrolled and did not vote at those
elections. Then
follows an allegation that what the
petitioner describes as
"the prohibition from voting or the otherwise absence of persons from
voting
in the said election due to
their non-enrolment" would have a variety of
effects, which she specifies, upon those elections.
The petitioner claims
that the
alleged removal of names is an illegal practice within s. 189 (3) of
the Act and goes on to allege that the election of the successful
Senate
candidates should be declared void; there follows
the prayer for relief
already referred to. (at p472)
3. Essentially, then, the petition complains of the state of the electoral
rolls upon which the last Senate election in South Australia
was conducted.
This remained the substance albeit unacknowledged, of the petitioner's
complaint when the matter came before this
Court sitting as the Court of
Disputed Returns. (at p472)
4. The Solicitor-General for the Commonwealth, who appeared by leave to
represent the acting Chief Electoral Officer, referred in
the course of his
submissions to s. 190 of the Act and to its injunction against the Court
making any inquiry into the correctness
of any electoral roll, and submitted
that
the matters alleged in the petition concerned the very matters which this
Court was, by
s. 190, enjoined from inquiring into - the correctness of
electoral rolls. (at p472)
5. Having heard the petitioner in person in reply to this submission, the
Court reserved its decision upon what was clearly a matter
at the very
threshold of the case and otherwise adjourned the further hearing. (at p472)
6. The Solicitor-General's submission is, I think, well founded. Section 190
of the Act is as follows:
"190. The Court shall inquire whether or not the petitionIt clearly precludes the Court of Disputed Returns from entering upon any inquiry into the correctness of any electoral roll and it is exclusively upon the alleged incorrectness of such rolls in the State of South Australia that the present petition is founded. It follows that the Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the petition; the petition is misconceived and must be dismissed in whole in exercise of the power conferred by s. 189 (1) (vii) of the Act. (at p472)
is duly signed, and so far as Rolls and voting are concerned
may inquire into the identity of persons, and whether their
votes were improperly admitted or rejected, assuming the
Roll to be correct, but the Court shall not inquire into the
correctness of any Roll."
7. That this must be its fate is clear enough from the terms of the petition
and from the petitioner's argument. The petitioner
appeared in person and in
the course of her submissions it plainly appeared that the form taken by her
petition did truly reflect
the substance of her contentions. The terms of s.
190 are so clear as to require no elucidation by reference to authority, but
if
authority be needed it is not wanting. In Perkins v.
Cusack (1929) 43 CLR
70 Starke J., sitting as the Court of Disputed
Returns,
was concerned with
submissions that in a particular
electorate votes were cast by persons who
were, but should not have
been, on
the relevant roll. It was their presence
on the roll
rather than, as here, their absence from it that was objected to
but
the views
expressed by his Honour are equally applicable to
either case.
Section 190 was in its present form and his Honour rejected
evidence
sought to
be tendered and bearing upon the correctness of enrolment; he
did so because
"that evidence would challenge the
correctness
of the Roll, and such an
inquiry is forbidden to this Court by the
statute" (1929) 43 CLR, at p 74 .
He later, in another
context,
said (1929) 43 CLR, at p 75 : "Under s. 190 the
Court must, for this purpose too, assume the Roll to be correct, and cannot
inquire
into its correctness". (at p473)
8. His Honour's decision has been followed by Maxwell J. in Re Darlinghurst
Petition (1951) 51 SR (NSW) 204 . In In re the Nash
Election Petition; Grant
v. Dunstan and Carney (1952) St R Qd 53 , Mansfield S.P.J., without express
reference to Perkins v. Cusack
(1930) 43 CLR 70 but after an examination of
earlier authorities, came to a like conclusion concerning the effect
of the
Queensland
electoral laws which, he said, did not entitle him "to inquire into
the correctness or otherwise of the compilation
of the rolls
used for this
election, but only into the conduct of the election itself" (1952) St R Qd at
p 64 . The Full Court's
subsequent dismissal
of an appeal by the petitioner
turned upon quite different grounds. (at p473)
9. It is not to be thought that the fate of this petition discloses a
situation in which a person whose name is wrongly removed
from the rolls or
who is wrongly refused entry upon the rolls is without remedy. On the
contrary quite adequate remedies exist for
those who choose to avail
themselves of them. Enrolment may be claimed as of right by those who are
qualified - s. 51 - and registrars
are required to give effect to valid claims
- s. 43. By s. 58 of the Act a person whose claim for enrolment has been
rejected or
whose name has been removed from a roll as a result of an
objection
may have recourse to a court of summary jurisdiction which is
empowered to order enrolment or re-instatement on the rolls. The Act
also
allows a person entitled to be enrolled but whose name
has been omitted from
or struck off the roll by error or mistake to vote
upon satisfying certain
procedural requirements - s. 121.
Quite apart from these statutory rights a
remedy by way of mandamus would
be available in appropriate circumstances to
enforce the
right to registration of a qualified person denied his rights and
for whom
for any reason the statute did not afford appropriate
relief. (at
p474)
10. Any electoral system which, instead of providing a means of putting the
electoral rolls in order before an election, allows
alleged errors in those
rolls to ground an attack upon the validity of the subsequent election exposes
to risks of dislocation the
democratic process which it is designed to serve.
Hence, no doubt, the provisions, commonly found in our election laws, for the
prior
adjudication of disputes as to the state of the rolls, such disputes
being treated as wholly distinct from, and not the proper subject
matter of,
petitions concerning disputed elections and returns. (at p474)
11. For the reasons stated above the present petition must be dismissed.
There will be no order as to costs, the Solicitor-General
having announced
that no such order is sought. (at p474)
MASON J. I agree that, for the reasons given by Stephen J., this petition
must be dismissed. (at p474)
ORDER
Petition dismissed.
No order as to costs.