No inference of guilt and no inference impugning the credit of an accused person may be drawn from the accused's failure to give an innocent explanation after being cautioned. A trial judge's comments inviting the jury to consider the exercise of the right to silence after caution when assessing credibility constitute a misdirection. However, untrue statements, false denials, and selective answers (whether before or after caution) may be used to show consciousness of guilt and to test the credibility of an innocent explanation subsequently advanced at trial. The proviso may be applied where the evidence of guilt is overwhelming notwithstanding such a misdirection.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 3 later cases that cite this judgment.