A witness summons may be set aside as oppressive and as an abuse of process where the witness cannot give evidence material to any legitimate defence and the summons was issued for the ulterior purpose of using the court as a political forum. Indemnity costs may be awarded where the party should have known, by the time of the application, that the legal position was untenable, even if this was not clear at the time the summons was originally issued. However, indemnity costs are limited to costs reasonably incurred, and the engagement of senior counsel may be disallowed where the history of the litigation did not warrant it.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.