The Court of Appeal held that a spouse's general knowledge of and acquiescence in her husband's breach of a restraint of trade covenant was insufficient to establish her liability absent evidence she was a party to the breaches or that they were put to her in cross-examination ([name withheld] and [name withheld]; [name withheld] dissenting). The Court unanimously rejected the trial judge's finding that Cradex was a 'sham' or 'facade' for the [name withheld], holding that evidence of [name withheld]'s control and involvement in establishing the competing company did not establish beneficial ownership of its shares, and that the facade finding was inconsistent with the separate finding that Cradex procured [name withheld]'s breach. On damages, the majority held that the pre-tax lost profit figure of $422,768 should be reduced by the 39% company tax rate to $257,888 ([name withheld]), while [name withheld] and [name withheld] held no tax discount should be applied where the damages award was itself taxable in the recipients' hands, yielding a judgment of $422,768 plus interest.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.