A head sentence of 3 years for misappropriation of approximately $14,000 by a 24-year-old first offender who pleaded guilty and had partly extenuating circumstances was beyond the proper range and was reduced to 2 years. However, a partially suspended custodial sentence remained appropriate notwithstanding the offender's youth, guilty plea, and lack of criminal history. The amount misappropriated is not determinative; the court must consider the offender's criminal record, age, plea, and motivation. Collateral consequences of a dishonesty conviction, including career damage and reputational harm, are relevant to sentencing.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 2 later cases that cite this judgment.