A sentencing judge's finding that an offender's psychiatric history has no bearing on the commission of an offence will be upheld on appeal where the psychiatric evidence is based on an unreliable historian and the mental state examination discloses no psychosis or organic disorder. Explanatory psychiatric material is of limited utility in sentencing unless it is attractive of mitigation. A sentence of 20 years penal servitude for wounding with intent to murder involving five gunshots at close range during an armed robbery is at the top of the range but not manifestly excessive.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 2 later cases that cite this judgment.