The Court of Criminal Appeal held that where a Crown Prosecutor cross-examined a defence psychiatrist using clinical notes of a non-called psychiatrist ([name withheld]) from prison medical records, and the trial judge gave comprehensive limiting directions under s.136(a) of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) restricting the use of that material, no miscarriage of justice resulted. The Court emphasised that experienced trial counsel's deliberate tactical decision not to seek a jury discharge, but instead to seek and obtain limiting directions, weighed against a finding of unfairness on appeal. The conviction for murder was upheld, the defence of diminished responsibility having failed at trial.
The full text is available to signed-in members.