› Whether failure to include joint enterprise in written directions for count on which convicted constituted miscarriage of justice
› Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985 (NSW), s 25(2)
Criminal Law
› Joint criminal enterprise
› Directions to jury
› Supply of prohibited drugs
› Whether jury adequately directed on joint enterprise as essential element of supply charge
Criminal Law
› Sentence
› Parity
› Co-offender sentenced by different judge
› Whether disparity in sentences required intervention
› Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985 (NSW), s 25(2), s 33(3)
Criminal Law
› Evidence
› Voice identification
› Admissibility
› Familiarity of witness with voice
› Whether police officers sufficiently familiar with accused's voice to give identification evidence
Quick Take
1Where written directions setting out essential elements of an offence are provided to the jury for use in the jury room, the omission of joint enterprise as an essential element of the count on which the accused is convicted constitutes a substantial miscarriage of justice, even where oral directions may have addressed the concept.
2A co-offender's sentence that is extremely lenient should not be taken as the yardstick for the proper sentence to be imposed on the appellant, though parity principles still apply.