There is no special category of 'relationship evidence' that permits the Crown to adduce evidence of uncharged sexual misconduct; such evidence must satisfy the same probative value threshold as similar fact evidence. In multi-complainant sexual offence cases, the trial judge must conduct a voir dire where the circumstances raise a real question of common cause among witnesses, and if satisfied there is no real possibility of concoction or other common cause, the evidence is admissible provided the similarities give it the necessary probative value. The right to silence does not preclude admission of evidence of silence as an admission where the questioner is not a person in authority and the circumstances are such that a response would reasonably be expected.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.