An express contractual term denying exclusive occupation cannot be disregarded as a pretence or illusory term in the absence of evidence of surrounding circumstances demonstrating that the term was not intended to have practical operation. The English pretence doctrine developed under the Rent Acts is policy-driven and does not apply automatically in Australian stamp duty or commercial contexts. The question whether the pretence doctrine should be endorsed in Victoria was left open.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 12 later cases that cite this judgment.