› Mitigating factors — drug addiction — limited weight
Criminal Law
› Sentencing
› Rehabilitation — prospects — weight in Crown appeal
Quick Take
1That an armed robbery is committed to support a drug habit is of little consequence in mitigation, particularly where the offences were planned and committed over a period of weeks rather than on the spur of the moment by an offender crazed by drug craving (applying R v [name withheld] and distinguishing R v [name withheld]).
2Where prospects of rehabilitation depend largely on overcoming a longstanding heroin addiction, giving them heavy weight may produce a manifestly inadequate sentence for serious, discrete armed robberies involving deliberate terrorisation of vulnerable staff; such robberies, each a discrete event, warrant cumulation.
3On a Crown appeal, absent specific error, intervention requires manifest inadequacy amounting to error in principle, and any resentence is moderated to reflect the element of double jeopardy.