› Serious question to be tried — balance of convenience — adequacy of damages — doubtful solvency of defendant
Receivers
› Appointment
› Appropriateness — less drastic relief available — injunction preferred — ex parte order — procedural requirements
Receivers
› Ex parte appointment
› Defects — no undertaking as to damages — indefinite duration — costs order without hearing respondent — failure to provide for service
Trusts
› Breach of trust
› Trustee proposing to pay disputed expenses — preservation of trust fund — interlocutory relief
Quick Take
1Damages are not an adequate remedy, and the balance of convenience may favour an interlocutory injunction, where the threatened payments would exhaust a trust fund and leave a trustee without assets of its own, and where recovery against its director is doubtful. That the trustee and director are 'on notice' of their obligations and personally at risk is irrelevant to the balance of convenience.
2The ex parte appointment of receivers to preserve a disputed trust fund is drastic and was inappropriate where a less drastic order, such as an injunction, would suffice. An ex parte order appointing receivers should include an undertaking as to damages, should not be expressed to endure indefinitely, and should provide for service. It should also not award the applicant costs out of the receivership without the other side being heard.
3Whether the exception in s 17A(4)(b)(ii) of the Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic) ('appointing a receiver') extends to orders refusing or discharging such an appointment, so as to dispense with leave to appeal, was left open; leave was granted by consent, if needed.
Case Details
Citation[1999] VSCA 212
CourtVSCA
JurisdictionVictoria
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 3 later cases that cite this judgment.