› Manifest excess — aberrant behaviour by middle-aged offender of good character — cumulative mitigating factors
Criminal Law
› Sentencing
› Appellate intervention — threshold for intervention where sentencing judge took factor into account but gave it insufficient weight
Criminal Law
› Sentencing
› Non-parole period — principles applicable — penal element — general deterrence — relationship to head sentence
Criminal Law
› Sentencing
› Plea of guilty — weight to be accorded — whether maximum discount warranted — presence of witnesses and other evidence
Quick Take
1An appellate court will not intervene merely because a sentencing judge gave too little weight to a factor the judge did take into account, unless the discretion clearly miscarried. A sentence may nonetheless be manifestly excessive where mitigating factors are considered cumulatively. On the facts, those factors were offending proved on the balance of probabilities to be aberrant behaviour, cogent and unchallenged evidence of good character, rehabilitation and poor health. A sentence that the offender would have to serve in full would then be more severe than necessary under s 5(3) of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic).
2When an appellate court re-sentences with a lower head sentence, the non-parole period does not necessarily have to be reduced. Every non-parole period contains a penal element and should not be set so low as to undermine general deterrence, even where an incentive for rehabilitation is sought.
3Whether serious related offences forming a single episode may each be given full recognition but ordered to be served concurrently, consistently with Pearce v The Queen (1998) 194 CLR 610 and totality, was expressly left open because the point was disclaimed by both parties.