› Application to Supreme Court for order to hold inquest
Coroners
› Inquest
› Effect of Coroners (Amendment) Act 1999 on right to apply to Supreme Court
Coroners
› Refusal to hold inquest
› Three-month period before Supreme Court application available
Statutory interpretation
› Amending legislation
› Curtailment of existing rights of access to court
Quick Take
1Under s 18(2) of the Coroners Act 1985 (Vic), as amended by the Coroners (Amendment) Act 1999, for deaths occurring after 1 July 1999 an interested person may apply to the Supreme Court for an order that an inquest be held only if, three months after the request, the Coroner has neither agreed to it nor refused it and given reasons; there is no statutory right to seek the Court's review of a refusal made and reasoned within that period.
2Where a Coroner has refused, with reasons, a request for an inquest within the three-month period, any remedy must be pursued, if at all, independently of s 18, presumably by way of review. The amendments were designed to curtail the rights of interested persons, as the Minister's second reading speech confirms.
3An application to the Supreme Court made before three months have elapsed from the request is premature and outside the Court's power under s 18(3). Any future s 18 application should be made on notice to the persons most affected, including those the applicant alleges were implicated in the death.