1The use of two completely disparate monetary figures in a statutory demand ($57,470.89 and $1,150,079) constitutes a defect capable of causing substantial injustice under s 459J(1)(a) of the Corporations Act, as it would confuse any objective reader as to the amount demanded.
2Failure of the accompanying affidavit under s 459E(3) to verify that the debt is 'payable' (as distinct from merely 'due') by the company constitutes 'some other reason' to set aside the demand under s 459J(1)(b), being non-compliance with a mandatory statutory requirement that cannot be cured by extrinsic evidence.
3The question whether a plaintiff who invokes s 459G relying only on defect-based grounds in the supporting affidavit can later raise a genuine dispute ground under s 459H after the 21-day period was left open, though the Master strongly inclined to the view that it cannot be raised.