Briant v Allan & Anor

[2002] QCA 157

Queensland Court of Appeal

Built by Barristers,
For Australian Law.

See how it works

Interrogate

Catchwords

1. Tort
2. › Negligence
3. › Medical negligence
4. › Cross-infection during medical procedure
5. › Whether trial judge's finding of negligence supported by evidence
6. › Whether mechanism of contamination established on balance of probabilities
1. Evidence
2. › Burden of proof
3. › Sufficiency of evidence
4. › Inference and speculation
5. › Whether findings based on legitimate inference or unwarranted speculation
6. › Whether plaintiff discharged onus of proof on balance of probabilities
1. Appeal
2. › Standard of appellate review
3. › Findings of fact based on inference rather than credibility
4. › Whether appellate court may intervene
5. › District Court Act 1967 (Qld), s 118(3)

Quick Take

A trial judge's finding of negligence will be set aside where the critical findings are based on unwarranted speculation rather than legitimate inference from established facts, even in medical negligence cases where the mechanism of injury is difficult to prove. Where critical findings are based on inference rather than credibility assessments, an appellate court is not constrained by the trial judge's advantage in seeing and hearing witnesses, and a new trial will not be ordered if the evidence could not support the findings.