When exercising the discretion under County Court Rule 63A.24 not to confine a plaintiff to Magistrates' Court scale costs, the complexity of unsuccessful claims may be considered where those claims are interlinked with the successful claim and share considerable common evidence. An 'all in' Calderbank offer made by a plaintiff is relevant to the exercise of the costs discretion, even though its 'all in' character may preclude direct indemnity costs consequences. A successful defendant who is the alter ego of the unsuccessful defendant and who incurred no separate costs may be refused a costs order.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 7 later cases that cite this judgment.