Where a local environmental plan imposes a conditional obligation on a council to acquire land upon notice, subject to the council forming a specified opinion, the council must consider the matter within a reasonable time. However, the majority held that the council's opinion is not rendered ineffectual merely because it is formed after a reasonable time has elapsed. The dissent would have held that failure to form the opinion within a reasonable time renders the acquisition obligation unconditional. The question of whether the council can defeat court proceedings by forming the opinion at the last minute was left open but the majority indicated this would be unsatisfactory.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 2 later cases that cite this judgment.