› Delay in disclosure to defence of evidence in possession of Crown.
Criminal Law
› Appeal
› Whether a miscarriage of justice
› Material withheld not of “sufficient relevance”.
Evidence
› Evidentiary Matters Relating to Witnesses and Accused
› Cross-examination of sexual assault complainants
› Significance of surrounding detail to reliability of memory of assault.
Quick Take
1Whether non-disclosure or late disclosure of material to the defence gives rise to a miscarriage of justice under s 6(1) of the Criminal Appeal Act 1912 (NSW) depends on whether the material had 'sufficient relevance to a material issue' such that the accused lost a fair chance of acquittal (R v Grey; Grey v The Queen). Even in a word-against-word case, not everything capable of bearing on the sole Crown witness's credibility must be investigated in full; on the facts, material of tangential relevance, whose utility for further inquiry was entirely speculative, did not meet that threshold.
2Credibility involves distinct questions of reliability and veracity. Per Spigelman CJ, a complainant's imprecision about surrounding tangential detail has few if any implications for the reliability of her memory of the central details of a traumatic assault. Sully J cautioned that, depending on the individual trial, testing such detail may be the only practical means of challenging the complainant's evidence.
3A trial judge giving the s 294(2) Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW) direction may illustrate possible good reasons for delay in complaint with examples not drawn from the evidence, provided there is no suggestion those reasons were present in the case absent supporting evidence. Balance in delay directions is assessed against the summing-up as a whole.
Case Details
Citation[2006] NSWCCA 314
CourtNSWCCA
JurisdictionNew South Wales
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 32 later cases that cite this judgment.
19 of the 32 citing cases carry a classified treatment. How each court treated it is available to signed-in members.