A person is not a material witness merely because they have a connection to the complainant or because they were subsequently charged with drug offences; the appellant must identify what admissible evidence the witness could give. Speculation about potential evidence is insufficient. A trial judge's summing up need not address every inconsistency in prosecution evidence, particularly in a short and relatively simple trial where counsel's closing addresses have already canvassed the inconsistencies. Written submissions accusing a trial judge of actual bias are improper where there is no ground of appeal alleging bias and no reasonable basis for such an allegation.
The full text is available to signed-in members.