The common law defence of necessity requires evidence that the accused honestly believed on reasonable grounds that the persons were in a situation of 'imminent peril' — peril on the verge of transpiring and virtually certain to occur. Foreseeable risks of arrest by foreign authorities and potential deportation to countries of origin do not meet this threshold, even where the persons face serious dangers in their home countries. Separately, while prosecutors should generally raise objections to defence closing addresses in the absence of the jury during scheduled adjournments, inappropriate interruptions will not occasion a miscarriage of justice if, evaluated in context of the address as a whole, they did not deprive the accused of the entitlement to have counsel address the jury.
The full text is available to signed-in members.