Where a prosecution witness deliberately gives prejudicial character evidence in a finely balanced circumstantial case, a judicial direction to disregard the evidence may be insufficient to cure the prejudice, and the jury should be discharged. The deliberateness of the conduct, the timing of the evidence (at the end of the Crown case), and the strength of the remaining evidence are critical factors in assessing whether a direction can cure the prejudice.
The full text is available to signed-in members.