A trial judge's direction that multiple counts 'stand or fall together' constitutes a misdirection of law requiring a retrial, even where the preceding direction told the jury to consider the charges separately. The correct direction is that the charges do not stand or fall together. A direction using 'vice versa' in the context of doubt on one count being relevant to the other creates the risk of impermissible reasoning.
The full text is available to signed-in members.