Siegwerk Australia Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) v Nuplex Industries (Aust) Pty Ltd

• 1. Appeal
  2. › Retrial
  3. › Where reasons fail to deal with evidence
  4. › Trial judge's failure to consider second expert test and to engage with central expert debate
  5. › Whether errors material
• 1. Practice and Procedure
  2. › Application to amend notice of appeal
  3. › Discretion to allow
  4. › Where issue pleaded but at trial appellant's counsel agreed point was not in issue
  5. › Whether point went to root of claim
  6. › Whether respondent's conduct of trial significantly altered
  7. › Interests of justice
  8. › Finality
  9. › Application refused
  10. › Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 37M
• 1. Insurance
  2. › Broadform liability policy
  3. › Indemnity in respect of Property Damage as defined caused by an Occurrence in connection with insured's business
  4. › Whether liability of insured in respect of Property Damage
  5. › Whether loss of use of tangible property not physically damaged but caused by physical damage to other tangible property
• 1. Insurance
  2. › Broadform liability policy
  3. › Definition of Occurrence
  4. › Whether event resulting in Property Damage
  5. › Whether 'neither of which is expected nor intended from any person's standpoint' refers to Personal Injury or Property Damage rather than to the event

Quick Take