The 'displacement effect' recognised in criminal identification evidence — the risk that viewing a photograph displaces the original memory — is relevant in civil proceedings, although with differences in application having regard to different standards of proof. A trial judge is entitled to have regard to this phenomenon when assessing the reliability of a witness's identification evidence in a negligence case. The existence of alternative possibilities does not defeat a plaintiff's case, but the tribunal of fact must still be satisfied on the balance of probabilities of facts establishing liability.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 6 later cases that cite this judgment.