A finding that a claimant has established a moral claim based on a deceased's promise to give them property enlivens the court's discretion to make provision but does not determine the quantum of that provision. The moral claim is relevant to the first (jurisdictional) stage of the inquiry, but at the second stage the court must still assess what provision is appropriate having regard to all competing claims, the relative financial positions of the claimants, and the statutory criteria of proper maintenance, education and advancement in life. A trial judge who treats a moral claim as effectively determinative of quantum commits an error warranting appellate intervention.
The full text is available to signed-in members.