In a civil circumstantial case, the coincidence of multiple individually significant circumstances adds to, rather than subtracts from, the probability that in combination they were causative. Mathematical probability theory (multiplying individual probabilities) is inapplicable to circumstantial reasoning. A trial judge evaluating causation need not be persuaded of the exact mechanism of failure; it is sufficient to be satisfied that the concatenation of circumstances renders the alleged cause more probable than not. Where a defendant alleges an alternative cause, the outcome should be decided according to which cause is more likely, and it is improper to take into account supposed but unidentified competing hypotheses.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 10 later cases that cite this judgment.
1 of the 10 citing cases carry a classified treatment. How each court treated it is available to signed-in members.