A person's reputation (e.g., for violence) is capable of constituting an extrinsic fact sustaining a true innuendo in defamation, even though a reputation may not reflect the true character of the person. The sting of the imputation rests on the existence of the reputation itself, not on whether the reputation is factually accurate. This confirms the trial judge's approach in [name withheld] v [name withheld] (No 5) and the principle in John Fairfax Publications v [name withheld].
The full text is available to signed-in members.