On an indemnity costs assessment, the onus under r 42.5 UCPR lies on the paying party to establish that costs were unreasonably incurred or of an unreasonable amount. A gross sum costs order should not involve a detailed taxation exercise. Competing expert opinions on costs do not necessarily require the court to split the difference; the court may prefer one expert's assessment where the other party has not discharged the onus of establishing unreasonableness.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 2 later cases that cite this judgment.