A trial judge who leaves an alternative verdict of manslaughter to the jury may describe it as a 'theoretical possibility' or 'not a realistic verdict' without thereby withdrawing it, provided the correct legal directions are given and the jury is told the facts are for them. Expressing the onus of proof in the negative — that if the defence case is reasonably possible an acquittal must follow — does not reverse the onus.
The full text is available to signed-in members.