Photographic identification evidence based on general features such as head shape and jaw line, without more distinctive characteristics, is weak circumstantial evidence. Where the prosecution case on identity is entirely circumstantial, the trial judge must adequately weigh defence evidence tending to establish the defendant was not the offender, including alibi evidence and physical characteristics inconsistent with eyewitness descriptions. A failure to do so may render the verdict unsafe.
The full text is available to signed-in members.