A formal requirement in a guarantee that revocation be given by pre-paid registered mail is not a penalty within the meaning of the penalty doctrine; it is simply a capacity to terminate by a particular means. A refusal to provide a new guarantee in the context of negotiating payment arrangements for debts owed to other companies does not constitute revocation of an existing guarantee. Where affidavit evidence attributing conduct to a company is infected by a common error (the company was not incorporated at the relevant time), a court may reject that evidence and draw inferences from the surrounding circumstances as to the true identity of the contracting party.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.