On a sentencing appeal where the sentencing judge was faced with two irreconcilable factual accounts, carefully considering competing evidence and preferring one version over another does not constitute House v The King error. Submitting that an alternative reasonable inference was open, or that findings could not be established beyond reasonable doubt, does not demonstrate the requisite error; such submissions elide the distinction between demonstrating error and attacking factual findings based on a mere preference for different evidence.
The full text is available to signed-in members.