A sentencing judge's finding as to the offender's motivation (anger versus fear) for a fatal assault will not be disturbed on appeal where the finding is reasonably open on the evidence, even where the offender gave sworn evidence to the contrary, provided there is a sufficient evidentiary basis including CCTV footage, the nature of the blow, prior criminal history, and the offender's demeanour. A sentence of 5 years and 3 months for a juvenile one-punch manslaughter, without special circumstances or an order for juvenile detention, was upheld where the offender had prior convictions for violence and was on conditional liberty.
The full text is available to signed-in members.