Where an accused's defence at trial was that they were not present when the offence was committed, trial counsel is not incompetent for failing to raise manslaughter as an alternative verdict or to call evidence of mental impairment, as those matters are irrelevant to the defence actually run. A proposed appeal based on such alleged incompetence will have no realistic prospect of success, and an extension of time to appeal will be refused as futile.
The full text is available to signed-in members.