A starting point of 12 months' imprisonment for aggravated criminal trespass and aggravated assault committed by a first offender of good character, who was drawn into offending by a co-offender and who suffered significant injuries during the incident, was manifestly excessive. A starting point of three months per offence with some concurrency was appropriate in such circumstances. A sentencing judge is not required to put a defendant on notice before drawing adverse inferences from the primary facts, and the decision as to the basis upon which to sentence is a matter for the judge, not the prosecution.
The full text is available to signed-in members.