When ruling on a no case to answer submission in a circumstantial case involving multiple related counts, the trial judge must evaluate the circumstantial evidence in its entirety, including the chain of events established by other counts on which the accused has a case to answer, rather than examining individual items of evidence (such as fingerprint or tyre impression evidence) in isolation. The judge must take the evidence at its highest in favour of the prosecution and draw all reasonable inferences in the prosecution's favour, rather than focusing on inferences unfavourable to the prosecution.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.