A sentencing judge must address the causal connection between an offender's traumatic brain injury and the offending when assessing moral culpability and objective seriousness; it is an error to substitute the question of whether the offender was aware of the wrongfulness of the offending for the distinct question of whether the brain injury reduced moral culpability by impairing thinking, judgment and vulnerability to influence. Where unchallenged expert evidence establishes that an offender's significant rehabilitative needs arising from a brain injury cannot be met in custody and require specialised community-based services, the evidence supporting special circumstances may be so overwhelming that a failure to make that finding constitutes error.
The full text is available to signed-in members.