A sentencing judge who accepts a causal connection between an offender's mental illness and the offending, finds moral culpability substantially reduced, and reflects this in the sentence is not required to make a more granular assessment of the manner in which moral culpability operated to reduce the objective seriousness of each individual offence. Stern indicative sentences under s 53A do not of themselves demonstrate that an aggregate sentence is manifestly excessive; the focus on appeal remains on the aggregate sentence actually imposed. Bare sentencing statistics without examination of the underlying facts are unhelpful on a manifest excess appeal.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.