A sentencing judge cannot make a finding that an offender has an 'abnormal sexual disorder which has not abated' in the absence of medical or psychiatric evidence, particularly where the offender's history shows no sexual offending over a period of 29 years. Such a finding, even if expressed tentatively (using the word 'suggests'), will be treated as a concluded finding if it is used to assess prospects of rehabilitation and to find special circumstances. Where the standard non-parole period is set at 80% of the statutory maximum, a sentence approaching half the maximum for an offence assessed as significantly below mid-range objective seriousness may be manifestly excessive.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.