Evidence of psychiatric conditions such as PTSD and ADHD that affect a child's impulse control, decision-making, or emotional regulation during heightened stress is not relevant to the issue of doli incapax. Such evidence may be relevant to mental health defences, substantial impairment, or the capacity to form intent, but the doli incapax inquiry is confined to the child's state of moral and intellectual development — whether the child has reached a developmental stage where he or she comprehends the serious moral wrongfulness of the act. A mental illness is relevant to doli incapax only if the disorder itself prevents the child from reaching that state of development.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 2 later cases that cite this judgment.