For Commonwealth Medicare fraud offending involving approximately $178,000 obtained over 13 months through hundreds of false claims, a well-moderated sentence on a guilty plea would ordinarily be at least three years' imprisonment with a material proportion served in actual custody, absent exceptional circumstances. Psychological reports prepared solely for sentencing must contain well-founded expert opinions identifying impaired mental functioning and a causal connection to the offending to warrant significant moderation of deterrence; speculative references to possible disorders and diagnostic labels without clear foundation are insufficient. Prosecution authorities seeking to appeal sentence inadequacy should press for expedited hearing dates, as delay of nine months combined with rehabilitative progress may result in the residual discretion being exercised against re-sentencing despite demonstrated error.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.