› Category 2 offences — exceptions to mandatory imprisonment — s 5(2H) Sentencing Act 1991
Criminal law
› Sentencing
› Substantial and compelling circumstances — exceptional and rare — s 5(2H)(e)
Criminal law
› Sentencing
› Impaired mental functioning — burden of imprisonment — s 5(2H)(c)(ii)
Quick Take
1Where dangerous driving causing death involves low objective moral culpability (no speeding, intoxication, distraction or prolonged inattention — only a momentary failure to give way with an obscured view), this low gravity may help justify rather than negate the s 5(2H)(e) exception to mandatory imprisonment, consistent with DPP v [name withheld].
2The cumulative impact of low objective gravity, severe pre-existing PTSD and depression rendering imprisonment substantially more burdensome (s 5(2H)(c)(ii)), a spouse's diagnosis with aggressive cancer and recent stroke, the offender's role as sole financial provider and protective parent for psychologically fragile adolescent children at risk of removal to state care, and non-attributable delay can together constitute 'substantial and compelling circumstances that are exceptional and rare' under s 5(2H)(e).
3Bugmy considerations arising from childhood deprivation and institutional abuse have limited work to do in reducing moral culpability for dangerous driving where the offender has been a responsible driver throughout adult life, but remain relevant to the overall sentencing exercise including the significance of rehabilitation efforts.
Case Details
Citation[2023] VSC 761
CourtVSC
JurisdictionVictoria
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 3 later cases that cite this judgment.