› Failure to examine juror under oath on likelihood of reaching unanimous verdict
› Whether mandatory precondition to majority verdict satisfied
› Jury Act 1977 (NSW), s 55F(2)(b)
Quick Take
1Before a majority verdict may be accepted in criminal proceedings under s 55F(2) of the Jury Act 1977 (NSW), both preconditions must be satisfied: the jury must have deliberated for at least 8 hours (s 55F(2)(a)), and the court must be satisfied after examination on oath of one or more jurors that a unanimous verdict is unlikely (s 55F(2)(b)). Failure to comply with s 55F(2)(b) means the accused was not tried according to law.
2The procedural requirement of examining a juror on oath under s 55F(2)(b) is mandatory and cannot be dispensed with; a majority verdict returned without that step is vitiated regardless of whether the point was raised at trial or in the original grounds of appeal.