Where each party succeeds on some issues in long-running litigation — here, the defendants' cross-claim was dismissed but the plaintiffs failed on their contractual damages claim, and each party won two of four accounting issues — the court may make no order as to costs. The defendants' successful resistance of the plaintiffs' contract claim can justify ordering otherwise under UCPR Pt 42 r 42.20 to forestall the usual costs consequence of a dismissed cross-claim. The overriding purpose under ss 56-60 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) may militate against a detailed costs allocation exercise where it would generate further argument and delay.
The full text is available to signed-in members.