The correctness standard of appellate review from [name withheld] applies to appeals from decisions to permanently stay disciplinary proceedings, not merely the [name withheld] v The King discretionary error standard. The prior stay of criminal proceedings on the same factual basis does not, without more, establish that disciplinary proceedings should also be stayed, given the significant differences in nature, purpose and procedure between the two types of proceedings. Loss of medical records does not automatically warrant a permanent stay where the respondent's evidence does not establish that the records would have contained material relevant to the specific allegations. Where a complainant is not called as a witness or made available for cross-examination in disciplinary proceedings involving serious allegations, the hearing may be manifestly unfair notwithstanding that formal rules of evidence do not apply in the tribunal.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 2 later cases that cite this judgment.