The Court sentenced a First Nations woman with a profoundly disadvantaged childhood to a total of 2 years, 1 month and 7 days imprisonment for wounding, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and family violence order contraventions, suspended after approximately 6 months upon entering a good behaviour order with intensive supervision conditions. Applying [name withheld], the Court gave full weight to the offender's childhood disadvantage — including out-of-home care, child sexual abuse, and intergenerational trauma — resulting in a substantial reduction in moral culpability that moderated general deterrence, punishment and denunciation, while maintaining specific deterrence and community protection. Commonwealth carriage service offences (threats to kill, threaten serious harm, menace/harass) were dealt with by way of fines where the prosecution conceded imprisonment was not warranted given the spontaneous, unsophisticated and unrealisable nature of the threats.
The full text is available to signed-in members.